The practice of cold calling—posing a question to a student who has not volunteered—has long been a contentious pedagogical approach within general education. In recent years, however, educational research has redefined cold calling as a potentially inclusive and equitable instrument for fostering engagement and critical thinking, provided it is employed with skill and consideration. Within the Drama classroom, where verbal participation, spontaneous responses, and collaborative construction serve as foundational elements, this technique exhibits unique and significant potential. This tutorial conducts an academic investigation of cold calling, examining its theoretical foundations, practical applications within drama pedagogy, and the necessary conditions to ensure it empowers rather than alienates students.
1. Defining Cold Calling
Cold calling represents a pedagogical strategy whereby an educator deliberately selects a student to respond to a question or prompt without prior indication of the student’s willingness to participate. Traditionally linked with high-stakes questioning in more instructive classrooms, modern adaptations recognise cold calling as a scaffolded approach aimed at enhancing equity, distributing cognitive responsibilities across the classroom, and cultivating a culture of attentive listening.
Cold calling is distinguishable from “no opt-out” techniques, necessitating students to respond regardless of their preparedness. Conversely, effective cold calling fosters an environment where every student is expected and encouraged to participate. This distinction is especially pertinent in drama education, where emotional safety and expressive confidence are paramount.
Last update on 2026-03-13 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
2. Theoretical Foundations
a) Sociocultural Theory
Cold calling aligns with Vygotskian concepts related to the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD). When educators promote participation from students who may not have otherwise engaged, they foster an environment where those students can deepen their understanding through appropriate scaffolding. In this context, drama educators may utilise cold calling as a strategy to gently motivate students to transcend their comfort zones in domains such as performance reflection, character analysis, or group critique.
b) Constructivist Pedagogy
Constructivist models emphasise active participation in the process of meaning-making. Cold calling disrupts passive learning paradigms and reinforces that knowledge construction occurs through collaboration and is a continuous endeavour. In the Drama classroom, where meaning is generated through embodied practice and exchange of dialogue, cold calling can further substantiate the notion that every student’s voice constitutes a valuable contribution to the collective learning experience.
c) Critical Pedagogy
Freirean pedagogy critiques the concept of the “banking model” of education and advocates for engagement through dialogue. When utilised in this manner rather than a disciplinary one, cold calling holds the potential to subvert traditional power structures, ensuring that the most confident or articulate students do not monopolise participation. This approach can provide a platform for quieter voices, challenge implicit hierarchies within the group, and promote more equitable participation.
3. Common Misconceptions
Cold calling is often misunderstood as a coercive tactic designed to catch students off-guard or punish inattention. In the Drama classroom, such an approach would be pedagogically counterproductive, potentially increasing anxiety and resistance to participation. Instead, contemporary research encourages a reimagining of cold calling as:
- predictable and routine rather than random and punitive;
- paired with formative assessment practices such as think time;
- focused on process over product;
- sensitive to individual learning needs and emotional states.
Reframing cold calling through these lenses enables teachers to deploy the technique as a tool of empowerment rather than enforcement.
4. Why Use Cold Calling in Drama?
a) Democratise the Learning Environment
Drama classrooms predominantly rely on collaborative efforts, improvisational techniques, and open dialogue. However, participation frequently skews toward confident, extroverted students or those with prior theatre experience. The implementation of cold calling techniques addresses this imbalance by requiring that all students contribute ideas, interpretations, or reflections. Over time, this practice can normalise participation and assist in establishing ensemble equity.
b) Develop Verbal Articulation and Reflective Practice
Articulating thoughts audibly, particularly in circumstances of moderate pressure, represents a crucial competency in drama education. The practice of cold calling promotes students’ ability to use language related to abstract concepts, including, but not limited to, symbolism, subtext, and motivation. When conducted in a supportive manner, cold calling nurtures critical thinking and enhances metacognitive awareness, especially during debriefing sessions, post-performance reflections, or script analyses.
c) Foster Active Listening and Attention
When students are cognisant that they may be summoned at any moment, their level of engagement generally elevates. In drama education, where the ensemble’s cohesion and attentive listening are of utmost importance, this increased awareness enhances performance outcomes and bolsters interpersonal connections.
d) Prepare Students for Improvisation
Spontaneous responses represent a fundamental component of drama pedagogy, particularly in the areas of improvisation and devising. Cold calling serves as a parallel practice, enabling students to respond authentically and with agility, even in circumstances of unpreparedness. This methodology enhances the cognitive-muscular response critical for executing improvised scenes, nurturing character development, and facilitating devising processes.
5. Conditions for Success
For cold calling to function as an inclusive and productive technique in the Drama classroom, several critical preconditions must be met:
a) Psychological Safety
It is imperative for students to experience emotional safety within the learning environment. This necessitates the establishment of norms that promote respect, the redefinition of mistakes as opportunities for learning, and the explicit recognition of risk-taking. In the absence of a psychologically safe atmosphere, the practice of cold calling may evolve into a source of embarrassment or fear.
b) Predictability and Transparency
It is crucial for students to recognise that cold calling represents a standard component of classroom dynamics, rather than functioning as a punitive measure. Educators can effectively administer this approach by providing clear explanations and sustaining consistent structures. For example, articulating, “I’ll be calling on different people today, and we’ll always take a few seconds to think first,” situates this practice as a normal and supportive aspect of each lesson.
c) Scaffolding
Cold calling should be systematically and cognitively structured. This includes allowing adequate wait time, providing sentence starters, fostering peer support, and implementing think-pair-share strategies before requesting responses from individuals. In a dramatic context, this may entail allocating rehearsal time prior to a spontaneous interpretation or permitting students to document their initial thoughts before expressing them.
d) Cultural Responsiveness
Educators should remain cognisant of the cultural differences that affect classroom participation norms. The practice of cold calling must not encroach upon a student’s dignity or personal boundaries. Alternative methods of participation may be more appropriate for students who experience anxiety, have trauma backgrounds, or possess additional learning needs.
6. Cold Calling in Practice: Drama-Specific Strategies
a) During Script Work
When engaging in the reading of plays aloud or conducting table work, the technique of cold calling may be employed to pose interpretive questions. For instance, one might ask, “What do you notice about the way this character speaks here, Sam?” This approach fosters close reading and encourages diverse perspectives on the text. Over time, it trains students to engage in active reading and to anticipate that their contributions will hold significance during discussions.
b) In Character Development
When examining character, cold calling can elicit spontaneous monologues, gestures, or reflection on the character’s thoughts. For instance, “Jordan, could you demonstrate how your character enters this scene?” or “Leila, what thoughts does your character have at this moment?” When employed judiciously, this practice cultivates improvisational skills and enhances empathetic understanding.
c) In Group Reflection and Feedback
Subsequent to performances, cold calling proves to be an effective strategy for encouraging participation from more reserved students during feedback sessions. Inquiries such as, “Ben, which choices resonated with you in that scene?” or “Tasha, in what ways do you believe the ensemble utilised levels effectively?” serve to engage all students in evaluative discourse. Additionally, this practice exemplifies the process of both giving and receiving constructive criticism.
d) In Devising Processes
Devised theatre frequently initiates with brainstorming sessions and collaborative decision-making processes. Cold calling serves as a method to guarantee that every voice is acknowledged during the initial stages of idea generation. For instance: “Ava, what might be a good image to represent this theme?” or “Isaac, how would you stage that moment differently?” This practice also mitigates the risks associated with groupthink or the predominance of a select few voices.
e) During Practical Warm-Ups and Games
Even during physical warm-ups or drama games, cold calling can be subtly embedded. For example, “Callum, give us a new freeze frame idea,” or “Yasmine, name an emotion for the next round.” These low-stakes moments help to normalise spontaneous contributions and expand students’ expressive vocabularies.
7. Differentiation and Inclusion
a) Cold Calling and Neurodivergent Learners
Students on the autism spectrum, along with individuals experiencing Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) or processing difficulties, may face challenges when participating in cold calling activities. However, through the implementation of structured routines and supportive scaffolds—such as advance notifications, visual prompts, or collaborative assistance—many students can engage successfully and with confidence. Cold calling ought not to be utilised as a method for testing memory or as a punitive measure; rather, it should be regarded as a carefully managed strategy aimed at enhancing participation.
b) Language and Literacy Considerations
Students for whom English is an additional language may require customised support, such as simplified prompts or sentence frameworks. Engaging in cold calling within these contexts can remain beneficial if articulated inclusively, for example, by asking, “Can you share one word or phrase that stood out to you?” This practice also reinforces the significance of multilingual perspectives in performance interpretation.
c) Trauma-Informed Adaptations
Drama educators operating in trauma-sensitive environments must meticulously assess the emotional climate of the room. Cold calling should never heighten emotional vulnerability or provoke distress. Strategies such as opt-in cold calling (e.g., employing cards, spinner wheels, or visual cues) or anonymous contributions (e.g., read-aloud slips) can accomplish comparable results with enhanced emotional safety.
8. Building a Cold Calling Culture Over Time
Cold calling works best when embedded in a long-term pedagogical approach rather than deployed sporadically. To build a sustainable cold calling culture in the Drama classroom, consider the following developmental arc:
Phase 1: Introduce with Purpose
- Explain what cold calling is and why it will be used.
- Use only low-stakes, open-ended questions initially.
- Model your own thinking aloud to reduce performance anxiety.
Phase 2: Scaffold Student Responses
- Use pair-share or group brainstorming before cold calling.
- Provide visual sentence stems or cue cards.
- Celebrate effort and growth over accuracy or polish.
Phase 3: Normalise and Expand
- Use cold calling across all classroom formats (discussion, performance, reflection).
- Emphasise the ensemble ethos: everyone contributes, everyone matters.
- Reflect with students about how cold calling feels and adjust practices accordingly.
9. Addressing Challenges
Cold calling, like any technique, may encounter resistance or challenges. Common issues and strategies include:
- Student Refusal: Avoid confrontation; offer “pass and return” options, or provide opportunities for private follow-up.
- Inconsistency: Use random name generators, wheels, or seating charts to ensure equitable distribution.
- Over-Reliance: Cold calling should be one of many strategies. Balance it with voluntary participation, journalling, performance tasks, and small group collaboration.
10. Assessing the Impact
Assessment of cold calling should be formative, reflective, and ongoing. Key questions for teachers include:
- Are more students participating over time?
- Has the quality of responses improved?
- Are previously reticent students contributing more frequently?
- Do students report feeling included, valued, and stretched?
Anecdotal records, reflective journalling, peer feedback, and video analysis can help Drama educators assess the technique’s effectiveness and iterate accordingly.
Cold calling, when executed with empathy, consistency, and pedagogical intention, constitutes a potent instrument in the Drama classroom. It interrogates habitual participation patterns, validates student voices, and fosters the responsive thinking necessary for dynamic performance work. Importantly, it advocates for a collective ethic: that the Drama classroom is not merely a stage for a select few but a rehearsal space for all students. When integrated into the broader framework of drama education, cold calling reinforces the fundamental lesson that theatre teaches us—that everyone possesses a role to fulfil.
Discover more from The Drama Teacher
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.